Back during our in class writing assignment, I wrote about the differences between the use of the terms "exaptation" and "adaptation," from lecture during week 2. Since then, I updated it a little and decided to post the current version today. Here it is:
Ever since the term “exaptation” was coined, it has inevitably been compared to the more common term of “adaptation.” Exaptation refers to a character that was initially developed for one purpose, but has since been used in a different way. One example proposed by some ecologists is that the warning colors indicating that an animal would be toxic to eat, such as on the Monarch butterfly, was originally a trait developed for sexual selection and mating preferences.
Many scientists have begun to argue that all adaptations could be described as exaptations, if you look far enough back in time. And therefore, no adaptations are exaptations, because they are all simply adaptations. Larson (2013) argues that a better use for the term exaptation is within its application to the ever-changing realm of technology. The transition between the typewriter and computer is simple in terms of word processing and the ability to write faster. But, the subsequent developments of all that computers are used for now is remarkable.
My research involves bees and plant-pollinator interactions. The differences between and within the six families of bees are astounding, and their behavioral differences make sense of these physical differences. However, to try to go back in time from today’s perspective and determine which traits were caused by adaptation and which were caused by exaptation seems illogical. In this light, I would argue that adaptation makes sense to use overall, but when describing or discovering changes happening today, exaptation may fit and be used accurately.
These differences are largely for semantic debate, as the act of describing a species today really only requires a word like “adaptation.” However, through the accurate use of the term “exaptation,” there is some room for more knowledge and description of current processes in some of the changes happening today.
Source: Larson, G, Stephans, P, Tehrani, J & Layton, R 2013, ‘Exapting Exaptation’, Trends in Ecology & Evolution, vol. 28, no. 9, pp. 497-498.