Wednesday, May 6, 2020

Oxygen increase drives gigantism


I decided to read the paper mentioned in this week’s lecture about whether oxygen could drive gigantism and could account for giant insects during the Carboniferous. The Carboniferous was a time of high oxygen concentration, and too much oxygen can become poisonous. Insects operate with a tracheal respiratory system, where tubes containing oxygen branch all the way to individual cells, circumventing the need for blood or other liquids to provide oxygen. However, this is one of the limiting factors on insect size, seeing as insects cannot grow too big to the point that they suffer oxygen deprivation because their tracheal system can no longer reach every cell. In this paper, they studied how aquatic life stages might’ve been the gateway for gigantism as a coping mechanism for rising oxygen levels. “Oxygen constraints on body size may be stronger in aquatic environments,” particularly because water holds less oxygen than air  and is more likely to decrease in oxygen availability as temperature and diffusion rate increase (Verberk). This temperature-dependent oxygen limitation can lead to reduced aerobic scope, performance, and metabolism, eventually ending in death (Verberk). In addition, aquatic insects or insects with aquatic larval stages usually have a closed tracheal system (rather than open in which air enters through a spiracle), which limits oxygen delivery and regulatory control over the respiratory system (Verberk). This paper stated that many gigantic insects were either aquatic or had an aquatic larval stage with oxygen limitation, which is when they first learn how to deal with and circumvent oxygen limitation due to their sensitivity (Verbeck). These insects’ internal oxygen levels would’ve corresponded with environment oxygen levels, where it would’ve been harder for them to evolve and adapt to hyperoxia, putting aquatic larvae at risk (Verbeck). Therefore, at a time where aquatic insects were adapted to normoxia but were dealing with hyperoxia, “larger body sizes may have been actively selected for to avert oxygen toxicity,” driving evolutionary increases in body mass (Verbeck).

Citation:

Verberk WCEP, Bilton DT (2011) Can Oxygen Set Thermal Limits in an Insect and Drive Gigantism?. PLOS ONE 6(7): e22610.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0022610

No comments: