Friday, April 10, 2020

Learning from Population Panic of the Past

Hey y’all! This week the topic that really interested me was the history of predictions about human population growth and the ways that future projections of population growth (or lack thereof) will shape society. Hidden Brain, one of my favorite podcasts, did an episode on this recently which I’ll attach below.

A Little History
Thomas Malthus (1766-1834) first brought the idea of human population growth to the public eye early on in the 19th century. He predicted that the human population would eventually outgrow the ability to feed itself, a prediction that has since been disproved because humans proved to be very inventive when it came to food production. Over a century later, a Stanford researcher, Dr. Paul Ehrlich, wrote a book, aptly named The Population Bomb, that incited worldwide panic about overpopulation. He wrote about the possibility of “massive, out of control, population growth” with the population reaching 24 billion by the end of the 21st century and global starvation. He emphasized that the points made in his book were possibilities, not predictions, but the picture he painted was horrifying enough to ignite fear in the masses. This panic led to a terrible series of global human rights violations in the name of slowing human population growth. The 1970s and '80s saw forced sterilizations, coerced abortions, and inhumane policies like China’s One-child policy, which was only relaxed in 2013. We now know, based on current data and predictions, that Dr. Ehrich’s warnings were extremely off. According to UN projections, the growth rate of the human population will be nearly zero by 2100, and the human population is unlikely to exceed 11 billion.

What This Means
The human population is beginning to plateau, which means we will probably see a decreasing number of people in the workforce as the population ages. An aging population will likely put stress on things like social security, retirement, politics, and healthcare among others (Bos and Von Weizsacker 1989). Dr. Sarah Harper, an Oxford professor and the guest on this episode of Hidden Brain, suggests that the natural movements of people, through immigration and emigration, is one of the ways to fix the decreasing number of people in the workforce. We cannot accurately predict what the aging global population will do to our society, and if history is any guide, we should see that sensational population predictions do more harm than good. However, we can use the data that we have and the current projections to think about how our infrastructure may change to accommodate the post-industrial stage of human population growth.

The Bomb That Didn't Explode: Why Our Fears About Population Growth Didn't Come True

References:
Bos D,  Von Weizsacker RK. 1989. Economic consequences of an aging population. Eur Econ Rev. (2-3): 345-354.
Mann, Charles C. 2018. The Book That Incited a Worldwide Fear of Overpopulation. Smithsonian Magazine. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/book-incited-worldwide-fear-overpopulation-180967499/

No comments: