When did life on earth begin? This is a question humans have been
wondering for thousands of years. The most recent advances in trying to
answer this question have been based on one specific rock formation, a
banded iron formation. A banded iron formation is a layered sedimentary
rock with very clear layers of iron. A simple argument for life, which most
of these assumptions are based on, is that life needs water and that life is
heavily reliant on carbon. A banded iron formation, with carbon-13
depleted graphite, checks both of these boxes as banded iron formation
requires water to form, and also indicates a shift in atmospheric carbon.
A specific banded iron formation, shows both of these characteristics and
has been used as an argument for the origins of life since 1988. This
banded iron formations was found in Akilia, Greenland and is thought to
be one of the oldest sedimentary rocks in the world at 3850 million years
old, Multiple papers have been published in both Science and Nature
arguing that the key to the origin of life was in this banded iron formation.
That all changed in 2002 where new analysis of the rocks, by
Christopher M. Fedo, Martin J. Whitehouse may show that the highly
studied rock may be formed in a very different way than previously
thought. Using more modern technology Fedo and Whitehouse were
able closely analyze trace elements on the banded iron formation and
found many inconsistencies. The trace elements of the Alkali banded
iron formation were inconsistent with other banded iron formations, and
instead indicated that the rock formation was an ultramafic igneous
formation (igneous rock with less than 50% silica content). Therefore
the banded iron formation is likely due to deformation or folding of
igneous rock making it appear like a banded iron formation. This
means it was not formed by water. This greatly depletes the
validity of previous assumptions made about the origin of life. It is
clear that the subject of the origins of life have not been fully
understood, and may never be.
Source:
Origin of Quartz-Pyroxene Rock, Akilia, Greenland, and Implications
for Earth's Earliest Life. Science 296, 1448-1452 (2002)
No comments:
Post a Comment