During our lecture on behavioral ecology, I was fascinated by the concept of kin and reciprocal altruism and why these characteristics may have evolved, particularly as it pertains to primate social behavior and large brain-body mass ratio. Ashton et al.’s 1998 article “Kin Altruism, Reciprocal Altruism, and the Big Five Personality Factors” looks at the two types of altruism as connected to the Big Five personality factors, a psychological model that classifies extroversion, agreeableness, openness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism along a spectrum unique to each person.
Within this framework, the authors hypothesize that kin altruism correlates with a high level of agreeableness and a low level of emotional stability, while reciprocal altruism will correlate with high levels of both agreeableness and emotional stability. Their line of logic follows that kin altruism relies on empathy, which can be classified as “low emotional stability” because of its potential to cause upset on another’s behalf. Reciprocal altruism, on the other hand, relies on high emotional stability (detailed by the authors as willingness to forgive and reluctance to retaliate)as the individual trusts their favor will eventually be returned and benefit their overall fitness. The authors conducted a study involving allocation of money to test this theory, and their findings generally supported their hypothesis.
I had never read a human behavioral paper that took an evolutionary perspective, and in its wake, I’m torn between two conclusions. My first response to the paper was that reducing all of human behavior to five traits, and a significant portion of our evolutionary history to two, is arrogant and simplistic. As appealing as these logical explanations are, how could we ever hope to understand the complexity of people’s motivation through such a binary framework? However, after more thought, I 180’ed; people are just animals, and it’s equally arrogant to pretend everything we do is so complex as to be beyond understanding and explanation. I remain torn on the issue and will probably just continue to defer to the experts, but either way, this was a fascinating article worth a read.
Ashton, M. C., Paunonen, S. V., Helmes, E., & Jackson, D. N. (1998). Kin Altruism, Reciprocal Altruism, and the Big Five Personality Factors. Evolution and Human Behavior,19(4), 243-255. doi:10.1016/s1090-5138(98)00009-9
No comments:
Post a Comment